Disclaimer: Just so everyone knows, I'm not getting anything from this. No commission, no kickback, no affiliate fees, nothing. One, we wanted to help, two it's a fun thing to do with the kids, and three... ok, fine if more people get to my site, that's cool.
Gino's Deli
Unfortunately these guys don't sell gift cards online but I bet you could call them and get one!
(608) 273-1981 (Madison) or (608)827-0999 (Middleton)
This place was requested by one of our readers, Laura S. I haven't been there but have always heard great things about it. They sell huge lasagna that you can eat for a week!